Visit ShareIslam Order Page and GET MORE. Free CD; Audio CDs; DVDs. DONATE - Share the Rewards! Join Our Dawah Team. A high quality video collection of Sheikh Ahmed Deedat's debates and lectures. Last Updated on Jan 22nd, 2012. Announcement #5 (Oct 22nd, 2009): Alhamdulilah, All.
Do they seek for other than the Religion of Allah.-while all creatures in the heavens and on earth have, willing or unwilling. Dr. Jamal Badawi is the director of the Islamic Information Foundation, Halifax, Canada. Dr. Badawi is a professor of Management at Saint Mary University in Halifax. Dr. Jamal Badawi is 'Professor Emeritus' at St. Mary's University in Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada, where he served as Professor of both Management and Religious Studies. Jamal Badawi; Occupation: Preacher, professor, public speaker, writer: Religion: Islam: Website: SMU faculty page.
Jamal Badawi's Misinformation and Misquotations. Answering Dr. Jamal Badawi. Jamal Badawi's Misinformation and Misquotations - Part 3[ Part 1 | Part 2 |. Part 3 | Part 4 |.
Part 5 | Part 6 ]Sam Shamoun. Badawi on the Preservation of Previous Revelation. The following point is an argument made by Badawi in one of his lectures titled. The Preservation of the Quran.
The lecture was held in Toronto Canada on July 1. In dealing with the question often posed by Jews and Christians as to why God would. Quran but not the previous revelation, Badawi cited the following verse. It was We who revealed the Torah (to Moses): therein was guidance and light. By its standard. have been judged the Jews, by the prophets who bowed (as in Islám) to Allah's will, by the. Allah's book. and they were witnesses thereto: therefore fear not men, but fear Me, and sell not My signs.
If any do fail to judge by (the light of) what Allah hath revealed. S. 5: 4. 4. Badawi claimed that this verse states that God entrusted the protection of the previous revelation. These leaders failed in their responsibility of preserving God's Word. Yet, unlike the previous revelation, Allah claims that it would be his responsibility to preserve. Quran. "We have, without doubt, sent down the Message; and We will assuredly guard it. S. 1. 5: 9. "Move not thy tongue concerning the (Qurán) to make haste therewith.
Answering Dr. Jamal Badawi: Jamal Badawi's Misinformation and Misquotations - Part 3 [ Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6] Sam Shamoun. Christian Muslim Debates - Dr. Jamal Badawi, Dr. Hussain Morsi V.S. Dr. Gleason Archer, Anis Shorrosh The John Ankerberg Show: Great Debates 1. Concept of God. Topic: Islam vs. The Christian Faith (Full) A Debate Between Dr. Robert Morey and Dr. Jamal Badawi Dr. Jamal Badawi is an Egyptian born Muslim Canadian. He.
It is for Us to. collect it and to recite it: " 7. Several comments are in order. First, the passage says nothing about the Jews failing to preserve.
Badawi reads this erroneous assumption into the text. All it says is that God.
Jews with his book. But this is the same with the Quran. Allah did not personally. Muslim community a compiled Quranic manuscript in its exact order.
Rather, as Badawi believes, the Muslims collected, compiled and arranged the Quran. And it. has been the Muslims who have tried to preserve and protect the Quran ever since.
This means that Badawi must assume that Allah used fallible men to collect and arrange the. Quran in the form we find it today.
Badawi believes that these men were able to do this perfectly. The evidence does not support this. Both the Muslim traditions and the.
Quranic manuscripts demonstrate that the Quran has been transmitted with literally. In fact, the Quran itself. Like as We sent down on the dividers Those who made the Quran INTO SHREDS. So, by your Lord, We would most certainly question them all, As to what they did." S. Shakir. Scholar in Islamic studies Alphonse Mingana comments on this passage. Finally, if we understand correctly the following verse of Suratul- Hijr (xv.
As we sent down upon (punished) the dividers (of the Scripture?) who broke up. Koran into parts,' we are tempted to state that even when the Prophet was. There is nothing very surprising in this fact, since Muhammad could. Mingana, "Three Ancient Korans". The Origins of the Koran - Classic Essays on Islam's Holy Book, ed.
Ibn Warraq. [Prometheus Books, Amherst NY, 1. Mingana records the Muslim reaction to Uthman b. Affan's burning and wholesale. Quranic codices. "The book, drawn up by this method, continued to be authoritative and the standard. A. H. under the caliphate of 'Uthman. At this time the wonderful faithfulness.
Arab memory was defective, and according to a general weakness of human nature. Believers have been heard reciting the verses of the Koran in a different way. This fact was due specially, it is said, to the hundreds of dialects used in Arabia. Zaid. was again asked to put an end to these variations which had begun to scandalize the. Prophet. That indefatigable compiler, assisted by three men from the. Quraish, started to do what he had already done more than fifteen years before. The previous copies made from the first one written under Abu Bakr were all destroyed.
The critic remarks that the only guarantee. Koran is the testimony of Zaid; and for this reason, a scholar. Muhammad, or whether it. Zaid on his own authority, or on the meagre testimony of. Arab reciters, does not transgress the strict laws of high criticism.
If the memory. of the followers of the Prophet has been found defective from the year 1. A. H. when Islam was proclaimed over all Arabia, why may it not have been defective from. C. E. when the Prophet was often obliged to defend his own life against terrible. And if the first recension of Zaid contained always the actual words. Muhammad, why was this compiler not content with re- establishing it in its entirety.
Uthman? How can it be that in the. If 'Uthman was certainly inspired only by religious purposes. THE TEARER OF THE BOOKS' and why did they fasten. He found the Korans many and left one; HE TORE UP THE BOOK'? ".
Ibn Warraq, p. 8. Mingana, in his article The Transmission of the Koran, cites Muslim historian al- Tabari. Ali b. Abi Talib, and 'Uthman b' Affan wrote the Revelation to the Prophet.
Ubai b. Ka'b and Zaid b. Thabit who wrote it.' He informs us, too. Uthman: 'The Koran was in many books, and thou discreditedst. Prophet's death, 'People gave him as successor Abu Bakr. Umar; and both of them acted according to the Book and. Sunnah of the Apostle of God- and praise be to God the Lord of the worlds; then people. Uthman b. 'Affan WHO TORE UP THE BOOK.'" (Ibn Warraq, p.
In the same article Mingana cites another ancient writer regarding the compilation of the Quran. The writer, a Christian apologist named Abd al- Masih al- Kindi, wrote an apology titled. The Apology of Al- Kindi at the Court of al- Mamun circa A.
D. 8. 30., approximately forty. Al- Bukhari compiled his hadith collection. Al- Kindi mentions the Muslim reaction. Quranic codices circulating. Muhammad's death. Then the people fell to variance in their reading; some read according to the version of.
Ali, which they follow to the present day; some read according to the collection of which. Mas'ud, and another. Ubai ibn Ka'b. When 'Uthman came to power, and people everywhere differed in their reading, 'Ali. One man would read verse one way, and another.
When this was represented to 'Uthman, and the danger urged of division. But they did. not interfere with that which was in the hands of 'Ali, or of those who followed his reading. Ubai was dead by this time, as for Ibn Mas'ud, they demanded his exemplar, but he refused. Then they commanded Zaid ibn Thabit, and with him 'Abdallah ibn 'Abbas. Quraish. When the recension was completed, four exemplars were written out in large text; one was. Mecca, and another to Medina; the third was dispatched to Syria, and is to this day at.
Malatya; the fourth was deposited in Kufa. People say that this last copy is still extant at Kufa. Mukhtar (A. H. 6. The copy of. Mecca remained there till the city was stormed by Abu Sarayah (A. H. 2. 00); he did not. The Medina. exemplar was lost in the reign of terror, that is, in the days of Yazid b.
Mu'awiah (A. H. 6. After what we have related above, 'Uthman called in all the former leaves and copies, and. Ibn Mas'ud, however, retained his exemplar. Ali has descended in his family. Then followed the business of Hajjaj b.
Yusuf, who gathered together every single copy. Among these, they say, were verses revealed concerning the House of the Umayyah. House of 'Abbas also with names. Six copies of the text thus revised were distributed to Egypt, Syria, Medina, Mecca. Kufa, and Basra. After that he called in and destroyed all the preceding copies, even. Uthman had done before him. The enmity subsisting between 'Ali and Abu Bakr.
Umar and 'Uthman is well known; how each of these entered in the text whatever. How, then, can we distinguish.
And what about the losses caused by Hajjaj? The kind of faith that this tyrant held in other matters is well- known; how can we make an. Book of God a man who never ceased play into the hands of the Umayyads. Ibn Warraq, pp. 1. Mingana concludes. Then al- Kindi, addressing his Muslim friend, says: 'All that I have said is drawn from. Kur'an itself, which is.
Ibn Warraq, pp. 1. Muslim sources are in agreement with the claims made by al- Tabari and al- Kindi regarding. Quran. For instance, Ibn Abi Dawud wrote. Many (of the passages) of the Qur'an that were sent down were known by those who died. Yamama but they were not known (by those who) survived them, nor. Abu Bakr, Umar or Uthman (by that time) collected the.
Qur'an, nor were they found with even one (person) after them." (Ibn Abi Dawud. Kitab al- Masahif, p.
Ibn 'Umar exclaimed. It is reported from Ismail ibn Ibrahim from Ayyub from Naafi from Ibn Umar who said. Let none of you say "I have acquired the whole of the Qur'an". How does he know.
Qur'an has disappeared? Rather let him say. I have acquired what has survived."'" (as- Suyuti, Al- Itqan fii Ulum al- Qur'an.
Ibn Khaldun comments on the incompetence of the Arabic scribes. Arabic writing at the beginning of Islam was, therefore, not of the best quality nor. It was not (even) of medium quality, because. Arabs possessed the savage desert attitude and were not familiar with crafts. One may compare what happened to the orthography of the Qur'an on account of this.
The men around Muhammad wrote the Qur'an in their own script which. Most of the letters were in contradiction.
Consequently. (the Qur'anic orthography of the men around Muhammad was followed and became. No attention should be paid in this connection with those incompetent. Muhammad) knew well the art of writing and that the alleged. For instance, they explain the addition of the. U 'I shall indeed slaughter him' as indication that the slaughtering. A 'adhbahannah. U). The addition of the ya in bi- ayydin 'with hands.
There are similar. The only reason that caused. Muhammad from the suspicion of deficiency, in the sense that they were not.
They think that good writing is perfection. Thus, they do not. Muhammad were deficient in writing.". Muqqadimah, Ibn Khaldun, vol.
Yet despite all this evidence Badawi still chooses to blindly believe and propagate. Quran has been perfectly preserved. Therefore, much like Badawi believes that Allah preserved and collected the Quran.
God Yahweh also sovereignly used. Holy Bible. And we.